Pizza Box Football Game Review

The Basics:

  • For ages 8 and up (publisher suggests 10+)
  • For 2 players
  • Approximately 20 to 60 minutes to play, depending on the complexity chosen

Geek Skills:

  • Logical & Critical Decision Making
  • Emotional Coping Skills
  • Strategy & Tactics
  • Bluffing and Misdirection

Learning Curve:

  • Child – Moderate
  • Adult – Easy

Theme & Narrative:

  • Coach your own NFL teams – out of a pizza box!


  • Gamer Geek approved!
  • Parent Geek approved!
  • Child Geek approved!


Pizza Box Football, by On the Line Game Company, is an American football simulation game. Each player plays the head coach, calling offensive and defensive plays in hopes of marching down the field and scoring (or stopping a touchdown). Games can last anywhere from 20 minutes to an hour, based on the various play resolution rules that are being used. The rules of football apply, so it really is an easy game once players get used to resolving die rolls. As a player, you decide whether to run, pass short or pass long on every offensive play. As the defense, you determine which of those three to defend against. Roll your dice to determine how well your team performs on the play, and adjust the board accordingly.

This game comes in a box which could have been used to deliver a small pizza, hence the name. The box helps to elevate the board, which allows the use of different colored pegs. The pegs are included for use as markers for yardage, downs, location of the First Down marker, and the score. There are several dice included in various colors and sizes, and charts for turning die rolls into play results.

The size of the smaller dice and the pegs do present a bit of a choking hazard, so this game should be played with some supervision around babies and toddlers. There have been some instances of the board warping, but not beyond being serviceable. The game is published by the designers, who have only created this game and Pizza Box Baseball, and the difference between this publisher and the larger publishers shows a bit in the components. Nonetheless, the game is a lot of fun and easy to understand!

Game Set Up

To play, the board is set up within the box and each player takes a team card with die roll tables. In the base game, these cards are identical. Cards for kicking and “mishaps” (fumbles and the like) are set aside and within reach. After determining who will receive the “ball” first, players take the appropriate offensive and defensive dice. This game is quick to set up!

Playing the Game

Plays from scrimmage start with the offensive player choosing a red, yellow or green die representing a run, short pass or long pass play, respectively. The die remains hidden in the player’s hand until the defensive player announces which type of play he will defend against. The players roll their dice, cross-reference tables, and generally roll again for yardage gained based on the first result.

Where this game really shines is when you play with the NFL expansions. These were sold for a few years for all of the teams by the publisher. During that time, and continuing until at least the last Super Bowl, they also published charts for the two teams in the Super Bowl as free downloads from the website. Additionally, a fan of the game received permission to publish team cards after last season, and so there are cards on Board Game Geek for each team based on the 2011 statistics.

What do these cards do? Well, with the base game cards, each of the two teams are identical. This means you have a sort of Rock-Paper-Scissors game going on which is somewhat influenced by the down and yards-to-go situation. The NFL team cards reflect the strengths and weaknesses of the individual teams, adding another factor in deciding what plays to call. It’s 3rd and 8, but I have a stronger running game – do I run? What is the strength of my opponents defense? It’s your call!

Winning the Game

After the game clock has run out, the game is over. The player with the highest score wins, just like in the real thing!

Game Variants

There are four variants to the game, all designed so the game fits the time you have available.

  • Red Zone Shootout: The 5-minute Red Zone Shootout game plays just like college overtime. From the rulebook: Each player will get a chance to score with the ball from his opponent’s 25-yard line. If the score is tied after each player has had a chance, play continues.
  • Backyard Brawl: This variant should last about 30-minutes. To quote: Each team will get 6 chances with the ball. There are 3 rounds per half, and each team gets 1 chance to score per round. In each half, teams will try scoring from their own 25 yard line, from midfield and from their opponent’s 25 yard line. There’s a play limit on each possession, but there is no punting allowed.
  • Smashmouth Full Game: The 60-minute Smashmouth Full game is just like an entire football game. Rulebook: This is the real thing, with 4 quarters, with kickoffs, punts and more. Turnovers matter. Field position matters. May the best team win.
  • Professional Full Game: This is also a 60-minute game. As stated: Now you’re a pro. The clock moves just like a real game. Manage it. Use your timeouts. Call hurry-up offense plays to get an extra score or try to come from behind.

To learn more about Pizza Box Footballvisit the game’s web page.

Final Word

This game is easy to grasp, set up and play. It feels like football, so it’s a great game for Child, Parent, and Gamer Geeks who love the sport. I have owned this game for a few years, and played it with my son when he was younger, and played with adults re-enacting the Super Bowl.

Example of the game set up – not shown is the pizza (which does not come with the game…sadly)

The caveat to this is that it tends to play very well with people who love gridiron football, and not do so well with people who don’t. Being a game that is heavily football themed, as demonstrated in the game mechanisms and game play, this makes total sense. It also has a hard time competing with football video games. Nonetheless, it is a great game, and definitely worth owning.

Tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

About Frank

Father of One, and Husband of One, Frank was introduced to wargames at the innocent age of 13, and had a share in his first subscription to SPI’s Strategy and Tactics magazine within a few months later. After only a year or two, he had been introduced to Basic Dungeon’s and Dragons, and played some form of fantasy role-playing from then through college. Discovering hobby boardgames in 2007, he now explores them with his 14-year-old son, their Boy Scout troop, and his regular gaming group. He teaches Chess to elementary students after school, too! Prior to joining the Father Geek Staff, Frank wrote for his own blog, Zwischenzug, where he expressed his belief that all games are educational games in some manner. His experiences have taught him that board games create friendships, build families, and teach social and other important skills to little ones. He is dedicated to helping families and friends find great family games and casual games to play. Frank can be found on Board Game Geek as feldmafx.

One Response to Pizza Box Football Game Review

  1. Pingback: Dice Bowl Football Game Review » Father Geek

Have an opinion? Like what you read? Thought it was rubbish? Leave a comment!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.