San Juan Game Review

The Basics:

  • Ages 6 and Up
  • For 2 to 4 players
  • 30-45 minutes to complete

Geek Skills:

  • Logical & Critical Decision Making
  • Reading & Writing
  • Strategy & Tactics
  • Risk vs. Rewards

Learning Curve:

  • Child – Hard
  • Adult – Moderate

Theme & Narrative:

  • Develop a thriving New World economy!

Endorsements:

  • Father Geek approved!
  • Child Geek approved!

Overview

San Juan is a card game version of the smash hit Puerto Rico.

The 110 cards in the game represent buildings, each of which has a building cost and a victory point value. Some buildings produce goods, others have special abilities. As with many other card games, the variety of cards creates a layer of complexity atop the basic rules, and replayability is enhanced through exploring different strategies underpinned by powerful combinations of abilities. The central concept of the game is that cards are purchased (transferred from a player’s hand to his tableau) by discarding other cards from the hand. In other words, cards are both currency and commodity.

On his turn, the active player selects a role: Producer, Trader, Builder, Councillor or Prospector. Then all players, beginning with the active player, perform the activity associated with that role.

In a producer phase, production buildings yield goods. In a trader phase, players trade those goods for cash, i.e., cards. In a building phase, players purchase buildings as previously described. In councillor and prospector phases, players add cards from the deck to their hand – the councillor phase benefits all players, while the prospector phase benefits only the player who chose it.

The game ends immediately after a player builds his twelfth building. Victory point totals are calculated and the highest scorer wins.

Little sister holds the cards for big brother

Final Word

This is the first language-dependent game that I played with my son, a bald-faced but successful ploy to improve his reading skills, not that he needs too much encouragement. While he understands the rules, he has yet to acquire the big-picture perspective required for a victory. He is learning quickly, though, with some additional advice from me. For example, his first strategy was to build an expensive building as early as possible; this is rarely a wise move as it is crucial to maintain one’s development pace throughout the game, and benefits of the expensive buildings only take effect at the end of the game.

This is a far heavier game than the others we have reviewed so far, and is not recommended for younger children. Older children and adults alike will enjoy the scope for experimenting with different paths to victory.

Which is more fun, posing or playing?

About Meng

Board Game Fanatic, and Father of Two, Meng is an Australian who became hooked on board games at high school, with such classics as Talisman and Diplomacy. Years later, he rekindled his interest while living in the United States, both immersing himself in the local gaming scene and also taking advantage of mail-order to expand his collection to some 300 items. After returning to Australia in 2008, and with little time left after work, study and travel, the majority of his gaming nowadays is with his two young children. Hoping one day in the distant future to teach them to play a rollicking game of Die Macher, in the meantime he provides more age-appropriate fare and tries to discuss some life lessons along the way. Meng goes by the handle meng on Board Game Geek.
Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply